A common question new students of Rule 23(b)(2) ask is why it exists at all. After all, if an injunction truly offers indivisible relief, why would one seek to bring it on behalf of a class? Wouldn’t the individual pursuing the injunction get relief for the class if she wins just by bringing the lawsuit
cohesiveness
Cohesiveness and Commonality – MD v Perry
By The Editors on
Posted in Certification
In the wake of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, plaintiffs and trial courts are still trying to determine exactly how to apply the clarified commonality standard of Rule 23(a)(2), and the standard for injunctive relief under Rule 23(b)(2). The good news for defendants, as demonstrated in the new case M.D. v. Perry, 2012…
“Future Injury” versus “Fool Me Once” – McNair v. Synapse Group Inc.
By The Editors on
Posted in Certification
To get lawsuits into court and past preliminary motions, plaintiffs often have to argue some pretty stupid things. They have to argue that they did not know coffee is hot or that they trusted Google Maps directions over their own eyes. Sometimes, to get a class action that far, plaintiffs’ lawyers have to argue…
No Shortcuts Under Rule 23 – Gates v. Rohm & Haas Co.
By The Editors on
Posted in Certification
The last few weeks have been exceptionally busy for appellate decisions involving class actions. In addition to Judge Easterbrook’s In re Aqua Dots opinion, the Sixth Circuit’s Pipefitters opinion, the Second Circuit’s Literary Works opinion, and the Ninth Circuit’s reversal of the Bluetooth settlement, the Third Circuit has offered up a pair of opinions…
Countering Injunctive-Relief Classes: The Cohesiveness Requirement
By The Editors on
Posted in Certification
When faced with a complex factual issue, where it would be difficult to certify under Rule 23(b)(3) (because individual issues of causation or liability clearly predominate over common issues), plaintiffs will sometimes seek injunctive relief under Rule 23(b)(2) instead. From a rhetorical standpoint, seeking injunctive relief under Rule 23(b)(2) makes a powerful argument for certification…