There is no question that Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes will be the most-cited case in class-action practice for years to come. But before Dukes, Amchem Products, Inc. v. Windsor was the Supreme Court’s definitive announcement of its interpretation of Rule 23 standards.
What’s interesting about the case is that it involved a class-action…
Brian Fitzpatrick’s argument that courts should approve more fees for class action plaintiffs’ lawyers has generated its share of discussion. And a few months ago, the Seventh Circuit weighed in (sort of), during an argument about fees for objectors in In re Trans Union Corp. Privacy Litigation.
Judge Posner (who has decided a…
Most professional objectors are fee-seekers (or, as one court called them, "remoras"). But not all; some, like the Public Citizen Litigation Group and the Center for Class Action Fairness, are non-profits that seek to keep class settlements for the benefit of class members instead of class counsel.
Alan B. Morrison, one…
Last year, class-action plaintiffs’ lawyer (and author of the New Jersey Appellate Law Blog) Bruce Greenberg published an article in the St. John’s Law Review on "Restricting Objectors." (The cite is 84 St. John’s L. Rev. 949; the Law Review appears to be a few issues behind in posting articles on its site.) Not…
Twenty-two years ago, political scientist Robert D. Putnam published an article in the journal International Organization. Titled "Diplomacy and domestic politics: the logic of two-level games," it argued that international trade negotiators have a more complicated job than most believe. Not only must they convince the negotiators across the table of the…
One of the larger points of contention in class-action settlements is the size of the attorneys’ fees. Indeed, with a few exceptions, no one defends the size of attorneys fees, and the most heated criticisms decry the size of the fees compared to the recovery the class actually receives. Which is what makes a…
When a defendant is faced with a class action complaint, sometimes the best strategy appears to be to settle quickly, before having to engage in costly litigation or burdensome discovery. But, as readers of this blog know, that strategy is not always as straightforward as it first seems. In today’s case, we have another…
Vanderbilt law professor Brian Fitzpatrick’s year-old paper “The End of Objector Blackmail” has received a fair amount of attention from various lawyer-bloggers and lawyer-tweeters in the last week. The chatter stems from the attention he draws to a practice known as quick-pay provisions – provisions to pay plaintiffs’ counsel immediately when settling a…
